On June 17, 2026, the Ohio Supreme Court issued a landmark ruling that reshapes how courts evaluate manufactured housing dog bite liability property owner disputes across the state. In L.H. v. Sun Secured Financing LLC (2026-Ohio-2219), the Court held that owners of manufactured home communities cannot be held liable as “harborers” of a tenant’s dog unless they actively shelter, protect, or exercise control over that animal. For residents who have suffered serious injuries, property managers navigating risk, and attorneys evaluating claims, this decision changes the legal landscape significantly — and it arrives at a moment when dog bite injuries are more costly and legally complex than ever before.
What the Ohio Supreme Court Actually Decided in L.H. v. Sun Secured Financing LLC
The case centered on a dog bite incident that occurred on a playground within a manufactured home community owned by Sun Secured Financing LLC. A child identified as L.H. was attacked by a dog belonging to a tenant of the community. The question before the Court was whether the community owner — not the dog’s owner — could be held liable under Ohio’s dog bite statute, which assigns responsibility to the dog’s “owner,” “keeper,” or “harborer.”
The Ohio Supreme Court ruled definitively that Sun Secured Financing was not a “harborer” of the tenant’s dog. The Court adopted the plain and ordinary meaning of the word “harborer,” defining it as someone who shelters, protects, or exercises control over an animal. Because the property owner had no direct relationship with the dog — did not feed it, house it separately, or control its movements — it could not be held responsible for the injuries the dog caused. You can read the full text of the decision directly through the Ohio Supreme Court’s official website.
This ruling overturned a lower appeals court decision that had applied a broader, decades-old standard for determining harborer status. The appeals court had relied on a framework developed over roughly 40 years of Ohio case law that, in some interpretations, extended liability to landlords and property owners who permitted dogs on their premises. The Supreme Court rejected that expanded reading in favor of a narrower, plain-language interpretation.
The decision also arrives in the context of significant legislative change. Ohio’s Avery’s Law, which took effect on March 20, 2026, separately strengthened strict liability for dog owners by introducing mandatory insurance requirements — including a $100,000 minimum liability insurance mandate for owners of dogs classified as dangerous or vicious — expanded liability definitions, and a tiered classification system for dog owners based on prior incident history. Read together, Avery’s Law and the L.H. v. Sun Secured Financing LLC ruling send a clear signal: Ohio is tightening accountability for dog owners themselves while simultaneously narrowing the circumstances under which third parties like property managers can be pulled into dog bite litigation.
What the Dissent Argued
Not all justices agreed. The dissent argued that when the Ohio legislature added the word “harborer” to the dog bite statute in 1987, the legislative intent was specifically to expand landlord liability in situations where property owners knowingly permitted tenants to keep dogs on their premises. Under that reading, allowing a tenant to maintain a dog on the property — particularly in a managed community setting with common areas like playgrounds — should be enough to qualify as harboring. The dissenting justices contended that the majority’s plain-language approach effectively rewrites legislative history and leaves bite victims without a meaningful avenue for recovery when the dog’s direct owner lacks resources or adequate insurance coverage.
Understanding the Legal Distinction: Harborer vs. Property Owner
To understand why this ruling matters, it helps to understand what Ohio’s dog bite statute actually says and how courts have historically interpreted it. Ohio Revised Code Section 955.28 imposes strict liability — meaning no proof of negligence is required — on the “owner, keeper, or harborer” of a dog that causes injury. This strict liability framework is one of the stronger victim-protection schemes in the country, but its reach depends entirely on who qualifies as an owner, keeper, or harborer.
An owner is straightforward: the person who holds title to or legally possesses the dog. A keeper is someone who physically controls the dog at the time of the incident — a dog sitter, a trainer, or a household member who exercises day-to-day authority over the animal. A harborer has historically been the most contested category, because it potentially extends liability beyond those with direct, hands-on relationships with the dog.
Prior to the L.H. ruling, some Ohio courts had interpreted “harborer” expansively, finding that landlords who permitted tenants to keep dogs — and who controlled the premises where those dogs were kept — could be held strictly liable for bites that occurred on their property. This interpretation created meaningful liability exposure for apartment complex owners, mobile home park operators, and other residential landlords. The June 2026 decision closes that door, at least in the manufactured housing context, by anchoring the definition of harborer to actual shelter, protection, or control of the animal itself — not merely control over the land where the animal resides.
How This Decision Affects Manufactured Housing Communities in Ohio
For manufactured home community operators, the ruling provides a degree of legal clarity that has been absent for years. Property managers who have grappled with how to handle tenant dog policies, what to include in lease agreements, and how to assess liability exposure after bite incidents now have clearer guidance: unless they cross the line into actively sheltering, protecting, or controlling a tenant’s dog, they will not be treated as harborers under Ohio’s strict liability statute.
That does not mean, however, that manufactured home community operators face zero risk. The Court’s ruling was narrow and fact-specific. It addressed the harborer question under the strict liability statute — it did not eliminate all possible theories of recovery against property owners. Negligence claims, for example, remain viable in certain circumstances. If a property manager had actual knowledge that a specific dog had previously attacked someone and took no action to address the danger, a court might still find grounds for liability under a negligence framework, even if strict liability no longer applies.
Additionally, the broader insurance and risk management picture has shifted dramatically in 2026. According to data cited by Dogster, the average cost of dog bite insurance claims increased by 97% between 2016 and 2025 — a figure that underscores just how financially devastating these incidents have become. High-profile verdicts are driving that trend. In February 2026, a Los Angeles jury awarded $5.4 million in Horta v. L.A. Animal Services, a case involving a Belgian Malinois attack at an East Valley animal shelter. In Georgia, a 2026 jury returned a $4.2 million verdict for an 82-year-old woman mauled by a 130-pound Presa Canario mastiff. These verdicts illustrate that even as Ohio narrows property owner liability, the financial stakes of dog bite litigation nationally have never been higher.
Comparing Ohio’s New Standard to Other States
Ohio’s ruling is notable in part because it moves in a direction that contrasts with legal trends in other states. While Ohio is narrowing third-party property owner liability, other jurisdictions have been expanding the rights of bite victims in significant ways.
New York offers the most striking recent example. In 2026, the Flanders v. Goodfellow decision effectively eliminated New York’s longstanding “one free bite” rule, which had historically required bite victims to prove that a dog’s owner knew or should have known of the animal’s dangerous propensities before liability could attach. By abandoning that threshold requirement, the Flanders ruling dramatically expanded dog bite victim rights in New York and aligned the state more closely with strict liability jurisdictions. For victims in New York, this change means they no longer bear the burden of establishing prior notice of a dog’s dangerous behavior — a significant shift that legal observers expect to increase the volume and value of dog bite settlements and verdicts in that state.
Ohio’s approach and New York’s approach reflect a genuine divergence in how states are thinking about the allocation of risk in dog bite cases. Ohio is concentrating accountability on the dog’s direct owner — particularly through Avery’s Law — while limiting the exposure of third parties like property managers. New York is expanding the pool of potential defendants by removing procedural barriers for victims. Both approaches reflect legitimate policy choices, but they produce very different outcomes for property owners, insurers, and injury victims depending on where an incident occurs.
Frequently Asked Questions About Manufactured Housing Dog Bite Liability
When Could a Property Owner Still Be Liable?
Despite the narrowing effect of the L.H. ruling, there are still circumstances in which a manufactured home community owner or operator could face legal exposure after a dog bite incident. The most significant remaining pathway is negligence. If a property manager knew — or through reasonable diligence should have known — that a specific dog posed a danger to other residents or visitors, and failed to take reasonable steps to address that risk, a negligence claim remains theoretically viable. Courts evaluating such claims would look at whether the property manager had received prior complaints about the dog, whether the dog had been involved in previous incidents, and whether the operator’s response to that information was reasonable under the circumstances.
There is also the question of premises liability. Manufactured home communities maintain and control common areas — playgrounds, roads, recreational facilities, and similar shared spaces. If a property owner’s negligent maintenance or design of those common areas contributed to a bite incident, that could serve as a separate basis for liability independent of the harborer question entirely.
Practical Implications for Property Managers
For property managers operating manufactured home communities in Ohio, the June 2026 ruling offers reassurance but should not be read as a green light to abandon risk management practices. The ruling narrows strict liability exposure — it does not eliminate all legal risk. With the average cost of dog bite claims having nearly doubled over the past decade, the financial consequences of even a single serious incident remain substantial.
Practically speaking, property managers should continue to maintain clear pet policies in lease agreements, document all complaints or incidents involving tenant dogs, respond promptly and in writing when concerns about specific animals are raised, and consult with legal counsel when incidents occur. Ohio’s Avery’s Law, effective March 20, 2026, now requires that owners of dogs classified as dangerous or vicious carry a minimum of $100,000 in liability insurance. Property managers who are aware of dogs in their communities that might qualify under Avery’s Law classifications should ensure that those requirements are being met by the relevant tenants — and document that awareness and those efforts.
Practical Implications for Residents and Bite Victims
For residents of manufactured home communities who are bitten by a neighbor’s dog, the June 2026 ruling means that pursuing the community owner as a defendant under Ohio’s strict liability statute will generally no longer be a viable strategy. The primary defendant in most cases will be the dog’s owner. Under Avery’s Law, owners of dogs classified as dangerous or vicious are now required to carry $100,000 in minimum liability insurance, which provides a meaningful recovery source for victims in those cases.
However, victims should not assume that the community owner is entirely off the table as a potential defendant without first consulting with an attorney. The facts of each incident matter — particularly any prior complaints, prior incidents, or specific actions or inactions by the property manager that may support a negligence theory. An experienced dog bite attorney can evaluate whether the specific facts of a given case open doors that the L.H. ruling did not fully close.
Will Other States Follow Ohio’s Lead?
It is too early to predict with confidence whether other states will adopt the narrow harborer standard that Ohio’s Supreme Court embraced in June 2026. What is clear is that the question of third-party property owner liability in dog bite cases is an active area of legal development nationwide. Some states may find Ohio’s plain-language approach persuasive, particularly in jurisdictions that prioritize textualist statutory interpretation. Others, observing New York’s simultaneous move to broaden victim rights through Flanders v. Goodfellow, may move in the opposite direction.
What seems unlikely is that the broader national trend toward larger dog bite verdicts and settlements will reverse anytime soon. With the average cost of claims having increased 97% over a recent nine-year period and multimillion-dollar verdicts becoming more common — including the $5.4 million award in Horta v. L.A. Animal Services in February 2026 — the financial and legal pressure on all parties involved in dog bite litigation will continue to intensify regardless of which direction individual states move on the harborer question.
Can I still sue the manufactured home community if I was bitten by a tenant’s dog on community property?
After the June 2026 Ohio Supreme Court ruling, suing the manufactured home community as a strict liability harborer under Ohio’s dog bite statute will generally not succeed unless you can demonstrate that the community owner actually sheltered, protected, or controlled the dog that bit you. Merely owning or managing the property where the dog lived is no longer enough. That said, claims rooted in negligence — particularly if the property manager had prior knowledge of the dog’s dangerous behavior — may still be viable and are worth evaluating with an attorney.
Does the June 2026 Ohio ruling apply outside of Ohio?
No. The L.H. v. Sun Secured Financing LLC decision is a ruling of the Ohio Supreme Court interpreting Ohio’s dog bite statute. It has no direct legal effect in other states. However, courts in other jurisdictions that face similar questions about harborer liability may look to this decision as persuasive authority, particularly if their state’s dog bite statute uses similar language. Residents and property managers in other states should consult with attorneys familiar with their specific state’s laws.
What qualifies as “harboring” a dog under Ohio law after this decision?
Under the standard adopted in June 2026, harboring a dog means actually sheltering, protecting, or exercising control over the animal. This requires a direct relationship with the dog itself — not just ownership or control of the land where the dog happens to live. Examples that might still qualify as harboring include providing separate housing or food for a dog you do not own, exercising regular custody or supervision of the dog, or actively protecting the animal from removal or intervention by others.
How does this ruling affect dog bite claims involving serious injuries or infections?
The ruling affects who can be sued under the strict liability statute — it does not change the nature or value of a victim’s injuries. Dog bites can cause devastating physical harm, including crush injuries, nerve damage, disfigurement, and serious infections such as Capnocytophaga and Pasteurella. The financial stakes of these cases remain extremely high, as reflected in verdicts like the $4.2 million award in Georgia in 2026 for an elderly victim attacked by a large breed dog. What the ruling changes is the available pool of defendants in Ohio manufactured housing cases — it does not reduce the compensation a victim may be entitled to recover from the dog’s owner.
What should manufactured home community residents do if they are concerned about a dangerous dog in their community?
Residents who are aware of a dog in their community that they believe poses a danger should report their concerns in writing to community management and document that communication carefully. Under Ohio’s Avery’s Law, effective March 20, 2026, local authorities have strengthened tools for classifying and managing dangerous and vicious dogs, including mandatory insurance requirements for their owners. Residents can also contact local animal control authorities directly. If a bite or attack does occur, seek medical attention immediately, document the incident thoroughly including photographs of injuries, identify any witnesses, and consult with a dog bite attorney as soon as possible to understand your rights under Ohio’s current legal framework.

Patricia Coleman is a Animal Liability Legal Researcher with extensive knowledge of personal injury law and settlement values across the United States. With years of experience analyzing dog bite claims only cases, Patricia helps injury victims understand their legal rights and the potential value of their claims. Patricia is not an attorney and the information provided is for educational purposes only.